DON’T Call Us – When You Can Handle Your Personal Injury Claim Without an Attorney

You can handle some accident claims in Colorado without an attorney. If nobody was hurt, fault is clear, and the dollar amount is small, you can often settle the claim yourself and keep the full amount. Claims with real injuries, disputed fault, or long-term costs are different. This guide shows you which claim you have.

Can I really settle an insurance claim without a lawyer?

Yes. Colorado does not require you to hire a lawyer to file or settle an insurance claim. For a small, simple claim, a lawyer may not add enough value to justify the fee. Most injury lawyers charge a percentage of what you recover. On a very small claim, that fee can cancel out most of what a lawyer would gain for you.

An honest firm will tell you this up front. We would rather you handle a $2,000 claim well on your own than pay us a fee that eats the benefit.

When is it usually fine to handle a claim myself?

You can usually handle a claim yourself when all of the following are true. Every item on this list matters, so read each one.

1. Nobody was injured. The claim is for vehicle or property damage only.
2. Fault is clear and the other driver’s insurer accepts it.
3. You know the full cost of the damage, in writing, from a repair shop you trust.
4. The total amount is small, and no future costs are hiding behind it.
5. No government vehicle or government property is involved.
6. You have the time and patience to make calls, send documents, and follow up in writing.

If even one item fails, keep reading. The section on red flags below explains why.

How do I handle a small claim on my own?

Work through these steps in order. Keep every document.

1. Report the crash or incident and get the report number.
2. Photograph the damage, the scene, and anything that shows what happened.
3. See a doctor if you feel any pain at all, even mild pain. Some injuries show up days or weeks later.
4. Get written repair estimates before you talk numbers with the adjuster.
5. Put every request and every answer in writing. Email beats phone calls because email leaves a record.
6. Do not sign anything called a release until you know your full costs. A release is a document that ends your claim permanently, even if you find more damage or more injury later.

What if the insurance company will not pay a fair amount?

For a free legal consultation, call (719) 520-9909

Colorado gives you a court built for exactly this. Small claims court handles disputes up to $7,500, and it is designed for people without lawyers (C.R.S. 13-6-403). The forms are simple, the filing fee is low, and the hearing is informal. For amounts up to $25,000, county court is an option, and many people handle county court cases without a lawyer too (C.R.S. 13-6-104).

A polite letter that mentions small claims court often moves a stalled property-damage claim on its own.

How long do I have to file a claim in Colorado?

Colorado sets firm deadlines, and they differ by claim type. Most personal injury claims must be filed within two years (C.R.S. 13-80-102). Claims from a car, truck, or motorcycle crash get three years (C.R.S. 13-80-101). These are two separate deadlines. Do not assume the longer one applies to you.

Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today

One trap deserves its own warning. If a government vehicle or government property is involved, a much shorter written-notice deadline applies, measured in months. Miss it and the claim can die no matter how strong it is. Talk to a lawyer quickly in that situation, even if you plan to handle the rest yourself.

When do I actually need a lawyer?

Call a lawyer when any of these is true. Each one changes the claim in a way that is hard to see from the inside.

1. You were injured and needed more than one visit to a doctor. Injury claims involve future costs that are hard to value on your own.
2. The insurer says the crash was partly your fault. Colorado reduces your recovery by your share of fault, and past a certain point you recover nothing. Where that line sits in your case is a legal question.
3. Your injury keeps you from working, or it may be permanent.
4. A hospital filed a lien, or your health insurer wants repayment from your settlement. A lien is a legal claim on your recovery, and handled badly it can swallow a large part of it.
5. The other driver was uninsured or underinsured, so the claim runs through your own policy.
6. A commercial truck, a rideshare vehicle, or a government vehicle was involved.
7. Someone died. Wrongful death claims should never be handled alone.
8. The insurer is delaying, or it offered a fast settlement with a release before you knew your full costs.

Why does the insurance company want to settle so fast?

Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now

An insurance company is a business, and its adjusters are measured on keeping payouts low. That is how the system works, and knowing it puts you on even footing. First offers usually come in low. A fast offer with a release attached is often priced before the full extent of an injury is known, because a signed release ends the claim for good.

You still do not have to hire a lawyer. But never sign until you know your real costs, and get advice when the numbers are large or the injury is real.

What does talking to a lawyer cost?

Usually nothing. Most Colorado injury firms, including ours, offer a free consultation. Injury lawyers work on a contingency fee, which means the fee comes out of the recovery at the end. No fee unless we win. So the math is simple: on a serious claim, advice costs you nothing up front, and an experienced negotiator who knows what claims like yours are worth could make a considerable difference in what you recover.

A good lawyer will also tell you when you do not need one. That phone call costs nothing and can save you from the one mistake, a premature release, that cannot be undone.

The short version

Handle it yourself when nobody was hurt, fault is clear, and the numbers are small and final. Get advice when there is an injury, shared fault, a lien, a government vehicle, or pressure to sign fast. If you are not sure which claim you have, call us. The consultation is free, and if you can handle it on your own, we will say so.

Free case review. No fee unless we win. Call our Colorado Springs office at (719) 520-9909 or our Pueblo office at (719) 543-9999.

Heuserlaw.com

Copyright © 2025. Heuser & Heuser, L.L.P. All rights reserved.

The information in this blog post (“post”) is provided for general informational purposes only and may not reflect the current law in your jurisdiction. No information in this post should be construed as legal advice from the individual author or the law firm, nor is it intended to be a substitute for legal counsel on any subject matter. No reader of this post should act or refrain from acting based on any information included in or accessible through this post without seeking the appropriate legal or other professional advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from a lawyer licensed in the recipient’s state, country, or other appropriate licensing jurisdiction.

Call or text (719) 520-9909 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form